It Could Be Worse, Really
Article by Rich Donnell, Editor-in-Chief, Timber Processing June 2024
The results of this year’s U.S. Sawmill Operations and Capital Expenditure Survey have us longing for the old days, though the old days were only a few years ago, when lumber prices were setting records and the homebuilding and remodeling markets were going gangbusters.
Perhaps the negative thing about surveys in general is that when it comes to reporting the results, as we do throughout this issue, some generalization has to come with it. That is, the survey may reveal a significant percentage of lumbermen who are feeling less optimistic these days, and perhaps downright pessimistic, but that doesn’t mean there isn’t a percentage who are more upbeat.
Results of the softwood lumbermen and hardwood lumbermen are broken out into two separate stories. But in this space I’ve always liked to combine the results to provide a snapshot look at the entire U.S. lumber industry.
As usual, considerably more softwood lumbermen weighed in, but in total the number of mills represented in the results by softwood and hardwood lumbermen is around 190. These mills vary drastically in annual production, which of course is the real world.
The survey was 24 questions long, but the one multiple-choice question that it hangs its hat on each year concerns how lumbermen forecast their “lumber business situation” for the remainder of this year and into next year, as in, this case, 2024-2025.
Only 1% forecasted it as “excellent,” while 7% said “very poor.” What about the in-between? Well, 39% said “fair.” That leaves 24% who forecasted “good,” and 29% who forecasted “poor.”
Looking at the bright side—why not?—that means a quarter of the lumbermen expect at least a good business performance in the near future. Don’t let the fact that three years ago 92% forecasted at least a good business situation, and in fact of that number it was 46% who said good and 46% who said excellent.
In other words, the survey this year shows a whopping 67% of the lumbermen have fallen out of the good or excellent forecast in three years.
But at the same time—looking at the bright side again—it’s not like lumbermen have screeched to a halt when it comes to capital expenditure. For the remainder of 2024 and 2025, 26% of them have committed at least $1 million toward a mill project. And 15% of those have allocated at least $5 million. Certainly not as a robust as in recent years, but still significant.
I always keep at my side the September 2009 issue of Timber Processing, which was during the Great Recession. It was a 24-page issue with seven pages of advertisement and one of those was a mill liquidation ad. It was the thinnest issue in the magazine’s 48-year history. In our 2008 sawmill survey that April, 70% of the lumbermen said it was the worst business environment they had ever seen.
I doubt that 70% of the lumbermen responding to the current survey would say likewise about the present business environment (though the recent demise of several mills would probably have those ex-managers in agreement).
I’m not sure if comparing a current situation to an absolute worst case situation is recommended in the field of psycho-analysis, but if it helps, have at it.
Latest News
USDA Appoints Six Members To Softwood Lumber
USDA Appoints Six Members To Softwood LumberThe U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) has appointed six members to serve on the Softwood Lumber Board. The appointees will serve three-year terms beginning Jan. 1, 2025, and ending Dec. 31, 2027. Newly appointed members...
BID Group Becomes Comact
BID Group Becomes Comact BID Group has announced it will transition to new identity, Comact, marking a significant evolution in the company’s journey and reflects its commitment to innovation and excellence. From its origins as an OEM, Comact has been...
Canada Challenges Lumber Duties
Canada Challenges Lumber Duties Canada will challenge the final results of the U.S. Dept. of Commerce’s fifth Canadian softwood lumber reviews, according to a statement from Mary Ng, Minister of Export Promotion, International Trade and Economic Development....
Canfor Closures Causing Ripples
Canfor Closures Causing RipplesCanfor Corp., which announced in early September the closure of its Vanderhoof and Fort St. John sawmills in northern British Columbia, citing ongoing financial losses, weak lumber markets, and increased U.S. tariffs, said it remains...
Vermont Announces Business Loan Program
Vermont Announces Business Loan ProgramA new loan program from the Vermont Economic Development Authority (VEDA) is now available to support businesses in the state’s forest economy. Three million dollars in total financing can be provided in the form of loans up to...
Find Us On Social
Newsletter
The monthly Timber Processing Industry Newsletter reaches over 4,000 mill owners and supervisors.
Subscribe/Renew
Timber Processing is delivered 10 times per year to subscribers who represent sawmill ownership, management and supervisory personnel and corporate executives. Subscriptions are FREE to qualified individuals.
Advertise
Complete the online form so we can direct you to the appropriate Sales Representative.